The state of California technology procurement: ‘A never-ending project’

Published On: April 20, 2026

By Dorsey Griffith

“Government right now is functioning on the cutting edge — of 1973.”

Those were then Lt. Governor Gavin Newsom’s words in his 2013 book “Citizenville,” an argument for government transformation in the digital age. Newsom went on to write: “In the private sector and in our personal lives, absolutely everything has changed over the last decade. In government, very little has.”

As San Francisco mayor, he had spurred the creation of digital tools for city residents to access city services; as governor of California, he inherited an exponentially larger bureaucracy but was no less ambitious.

On his first full day in office in 2019, a year after the deadliest and most destructive wildfire on record, he directed state agencies to “develop a new iterative procurement approach” to obtain technology to accelerate wildfire response, a plan he called Innovation Procurement Sprint. Departments were directed to solicit solutions from vendors through a process called the Request for Innovative Ideas, or RFI2 , for pilot projects. Two were selected: a platform for predicting wildfire paths and another for detecting wildfire ignition points.

While specific to CalFire and the Department of General Services (DGS) operations, the action reflected Newsom’s overarching vision to streamline technology procurement across all state government. He argued that overhauling procurement would reduce barriers to innovation, end excessive delays in acquiring and implementing large new systems and cost overruns, and prevent the all-too-frequent project failures that cost taxpayers millions of dollars. Ultimately, a more agile, modular, cost-efficient system would also better serve and engage citizens in the business of government.

As Newsom’s second term and tenure as governor nears an end, the GovReport spoke with current and former state technology leaders, including some now on the vendor side, to gauge whether the Newsom administration has achieved its goal and what obstacles remain. The broad consensus is that the big ship that is California is slowly turning in the right direction, but that an emphasis on compliance, which stifles procurement innovation, persists.

Pandemic-inspired innovation

Newsom was in office just over a year when the COVID pandemic struck, and disseminating government information quickly became critical to saving lives. His State Chief Information Officer (CIO) and California Department of Technology (CDT) Director, Amy Tong, had already been devising ways to fix the procurement system to enable a faster technology and innovation cycle.

“Then, boom, COVID hits, everything has to go to remote access, which inevitably requires a lot of technology,” said Tong, who recently left state government. “(COVID) was the accelerator to go very fast to adopt more technology than anyone at the time was comfortable with.”

“He was the right person to meet the moment,” she said of Newsom. “He pushed to put technology at the forefront of problem-solving as opposed to seeing technology in the background as a support service.”

Emergency funding was unleashed, and Tong and her team moved quickly, while maintaining a competitive procurement process. She and her team worked with technology vendors, academic experts and officials from various state departments to create several digital tools to help government entities and residents respond to evolving pandemic needs. They set up systems to manage the availability and distribution of pandemic supplies, hospital beds and other equipment, and they made vaccine verification, finding testing sites, contact tracing and reporting known COVID exposures as easy as downloading an app on a mobile phone.

The approach represented a striking shift in how the state acquired and deployed technology to solve problems for the government and citizens. But since then, Tong said, while procurement modernization has continued, the guardrails once blamed for stalling and stifling innovation are going back up. The focus has shifted back toward risk avoidance rather than solving problems in the most agile, iterative way to achieve the desired outcome.

“They’re spending way too much time getting their i’s dotted and t’s crossed in the process of procurement,” she said. “There are provisions in our procurement that are way too risk-averse that slow things down.”

Lloyd Levine, a former state legislator who now works for T-Mobile on its state government strategy, has been a national leader for technology procurement reform. In his book, “Technology vs. Government,” he argues that the purpose of the procurement process should be to ensure government employees have timely access to the most current tools they need to get their jobs done efficiently and effectively – and do so with sufficient transparency to guard against malfeasance and protect taxpayers.

Levine said Newsom had a strong start with his fight to create the ODI, but that the double crisis of the PG&E bankruptcy and the COVID pandemic seemed to divert his attention from a proactive, technology-focused agenda.

Levine said the technology procurement process in California and many other states remains antiquated and antithetical to the way technology is developed and deployed.

“The process has overtaken the purpose,” he said. “We have become so encumbered by the process that we have lost sight of the actual purpose. The process… takes forever and often results in less-than-ideal outcomes.”

Asked to grade the governor on procurement modernization since his election, Levine said, “I’d give him an incomplete.”

A new project approval lifecycle is unveiled

After successfully guiding system innovations for enrolling Covered California insurers, Hayley Figeroid was tapped in 2022 by the Newsom administration to serve in its newly established Office of Digital Innovation (ODI). Now known as the Office of Data and Innovation, ODI was set up as a consultancy for state departments seeking to solve problems through technology, data, and service design.

“We had data scientists, a product team, user-experience experts — what you see in private technology,” she said. “We were small and new, and other state departments didn’t understand. It was, ‘Bring us your problems and we’ will fix them for free.’”

Later, as deputy director of strategic initiatives, Figeroid helped develop a system for planning, approving and implementing new state Generative AI technology. She supported the California Department of Technology’s (CDT’s) transition from the Project Approval Lifecycle (PAL), which requires several stages of upfront planning and analysis across agencies, to the Project Delivery Lifecycle (PDL), in which upfront work is done to refine the problem statement, vendor ideas are tested and “minimal viable projects” (MVPs) are developed before a technology solution is scaled. This more iterative approach was designed to validate solutions earlier and spend state resources more prudently. It was also intended to speed Generative AI adoption across state functions.

Figeroid and her colleague Tim Issertell, CDT’s deputy director of the California Project Management Office, took the plan on the road, presenting the PDL approach to state procurement specialists and technology vendors with the goal of replacing PAL with PDL for state procurement.

Andrea Wallin-Rohmann, a former CDT chief deputy and Department of Corrections CIO who now works for an AI solutions provider, said she’s encouraged by the CDT’s move to the PDL, but feels it hasn’t gone far enough.

“I am not 100% convinced that we are not still ‘time and process’ without ‘time and solution,” she said, referring to a process focused on compliance vs. outcomes. She added that the projects put out to bid do not emphasize the need for human-centered design to improve the experience for people who use the technology.

“At the end of the day, departments say, ‘I have to be responsive to my users, the public using our services,’” she said. “We have to build systems that meet their needs, and that is not part of the process.”

Nick Maduros, secretary of the Government Operations Agency, which oversees the CDT, emphasized that procurement has become too costly for everyone, and in his first year in the job, he has focused his reform efforts on fixing the system to protect taxpayers.

“We have set up a system where too many (state) departments are spending too many resources, including a lot of consulting resources, to put together plans,” he said. “They might spend years putting together plans rather than getting to the doing. It hasn’t led to the most successful outcomes.”

Figeroid, now a consultant with Rancho Cordova-based Clutch, said that from her perspective, the biggest barrier is how state tech projects are funded.

“A lot of this comes down to the budget cycle in California, which has not been updated for 150 years,” she said. “You have to say you know exactly what you need a year and a half in advance, then it takes two years of building. It doesn’t allow teams to be responsive. CDT applies oversight appropriately. But functioning in an ecosystem that can’t be responsive to technology updates, which might happen between when a department submits a change proposal, goes to market, gets a vendor, and builds the thing – that’s a long runway.”

Show me what you’ve got

State technology leaders have long understood that vendor-state relationships can be fraught. The rigid, up-front process for procuring large technology projects has prevented smaller, more innovative technology companies from getting in the door. Large companies that can afford consultants, have political connections and experience on big state tech projects are far more likely to win the jobs. At the same time, these relationships can be adversarial, particularly when project budgets soar, change orders multiply and state officials must face legislators’ ire for costly failures. The showdowns can lead to additional regulations and compliance requirements for both the state and vendors, making procurement more cumbersome for everyone.

The Newsom administration has worked to disrupt these patterns by inviting and partnering with vendors of all sizes at the outset of a project to first identify and understand the problem to be solved, conduct pilots for promising ideas and gradually build the most effective ones to scale.

“We are trying to open the aperture for who can get government contracts,” said Maduros. “Too often, to get a government contract, you have to have had a prior government contract, or you have to show that there are five others who want to buy your product. We are awarding the same repeat players, who may be great, but not the most innovative.”

The use of “innovation showcases,” pilot projects and RFI2 has enabled a more diverse, often more innovative, group of vendors to demonstrate their capabilities and solutions to state procurement specialists.

Some of these efforts have been fruitful: After submitting an RFI2 , Northrup Grumman and Technoylva were awarded contracts for their wildfire response technology, and RFI2 was also used to build out a major portion of the Middle-Mile Broadband Initiative. As part of an Executive Order on GenAI, the Newsom administration used RFI2 to pilot GenAI solutions to address dangerous intersections, study traffic patterns and reduce congestion for Caltrans. It was also used to make the Tax and Fee Administration’s call center more efficient.

Maduros said RFI2 is a potential money-saver for taxpayers.

“We are so close to the epicenter of the start-up culture, and yet it’s a world apart from where we are in state government and where we look for assistance,” he said. “We need to break down those barriers so it’s easier for people to come in and provide services to the state. A lot of these startups and smaller businesses can provide superior services and, in many cases, at lower prices.”

The RFI2 process has become ingrained in government procurement operations, Maduros said, but added, “I would like to see (it used for) larger IT projects to make them more modular and smaller. We should not be having half a billion or billion-dollar projects.”

Dan Kim was director of the Department of General Services from 2015 to 2021 and now directs procurement for the Weideman Group, which advises companies on getting government contracts.

Kim credits the Newsom administration and CDT for helping change the culture around product development through the RFI2 process, but he also sees barriers to expanding its implementation, both for the state and the vendors.

“The challenge is that it takes a lot of time and effort to conduct an RFI2 ,” he said. “The question is the opportunity cost,” he said, referring to the state’s limited number of IT and procurement experts to shepherd the process. “How many staff are you involving to get it in place? How involved does the vendor have to be?”

Kim also wondered whether the state had plans to develop RFI2 toolkits and other resources to better enable the process. “How do you create a template? Departments need a roadmap to help guide them. DGS and CDT staff may be overwhelmed with other responsibilities.”

Vendors, he added, appreciate the more collaborative approach, but “the RFI2 process requires a significant investment, so the lack of certainty weighs on them and makes them question whether the investment is worth the payoff.”

Wallin-Rohmann agreed. “In concept, it’s great,” she said. “But vendors have presented and heard nothing, and it’s been months. It’s part of the frustration. A lot of people put a lot of effort into creating proposals, and they’re in a black hole.”

Turning the ship with fixes big and small

For all the lofty intentions of the Newsom administration to modernize the process, observers acknowledge that several obstacles are hampering progress, but they generally agree that there are nuts-and-bolts fixes, as well as broader reforms, that can further streamline technology procurement now and into the next state administration.

Wallin-Rohmann applauds the state for seeking AI solutions, but suggested it use AI technology to make the procurement decision-making process itself less cumbersome. AI could, for example, verify vendor eligibility and eliminate duplicative vendor scoring and validation, and help standardize proposal submission by moving from paper documents to an online system that collects data, ultimately enhancing the process by cutting time-consuming analysis.

Wallin-Rohmann added that vendors should be required to provide services along with solutions: “We have heard from state executives that they want to maintain a relationship with them until they can utilize the tool so it’s functioning right, yet we have contract vehicles such as Managed Cloud Services provided through CDT that only allow the procurement of products (IaaS, PaaS, SaaS), not related services. That means departments have to do a separate procurement for the services.”

Among other reforms, Levine suggested that requests for vendor proposals (RFPs) could be made easier to complete.

“Stop putting in things that become trip wires,” he said. “Companies have been disqualified for ‘transgressions’ that have nothing to do with their ability to perform the work. Governments are artificially limiting their own access to technology by disqualifying companies for things like using the wrong font. There are so many requirements in the process; only a small number of companies can respond – the ones with the volume of employees and lawyers to do it all.”

Maduros agreed. “I think we need to go away from a model where we reward people for being good at getting government contracts and instead reward people for being good at delivering great services to the government. We have sometimes gotten our signals crossed.”

He said that many vendors reject the state’s onerous terms and conditions.

“Too many bidders drop out because they won’t accept the state’s terms or they lead to the state paying more without actually receiving any greater legal protection,” he said. “We need to figure out how to bring the full spectrum of the California innovation economy into state government.”

Tong would like to see technology procurement oversight updated to eliminate needless delays.

“It takes 18 months to go through the budget change process to approval and investment,” she said. “How do you keep up with technologies, which move on a weekly and monthly basis, while maintaining proper oversight? We need to decouple the legislative budget cycle from technology investment.”

Maduros said that while the legislature has an important role in oversight, he agrees that a new funding model is necessary to procure and implement new technology much more quickly. Several approaches are being considered, he added, including departmental revolving fund accounts that can be drawn on when IT needs arise, especially for smaller projects.

“It would provide incentives (for departments) to save money,” he said.

Five years hence, Maduros said his greatest hope is to establish a culture of buying technology solutions incrementally, rather than through giant expenditures, so that procurement happens faster and costs less.

“Government, as with everyone’s personal life, is a non-stop process of constant improvement,” he said. “This is an effort that takes every day waking up and thinking, ‘How can we make some small improvement today and more small improvements tomorrow?’ It’s a never-ending project.”

About the Author: Dorsey Griffith

Dorsey Griffith is a seasoned, strategic communications professional and veteran journalist with more than 30 years of experience in the private and public sectors. She spent more than 20 years as a newspaper reporter focused on health and medicine with additional experience covering education, government and regional affairs.